Home
FALLOWED Land Registry
Factors

Suitability Criteria

Match measures to your conditions using the criteria tables below

Use the tables below to match measures to your conditions. Criteria are indicative; site-specific assessment is recommended. The table below defines each evaluation criterion (description and rationale) from the guidebook. The two matrices that follow show which criteria apply to each measure: an “X” indicates that the evaluation factor should be considered when implementing that measure.

Selection Criteria — Definitions and Rationale

Evaluation criteria Description Rationale
Farm factors
Cost Cost of changing practices or crops, including removal of crop, new equipment required for different crop, or loss of income and potential mitigation by new income from new use. May be significant cost associated with removal of perennial crop vs. annual crop; land surface modifications.
Crop type Crop classification such as grapes, vegetables, grain and hay. Annual crops can be converted immediately whereas perennial crops may not be.
Farm practices Any practices such as cover cropping, tillage, crop rotations, multi-cropping, seasonality of crops. Includes practices of growing specific crops. Some practices are associated with more or less water use. Landowners may not have knowledge of growing different crops or different types of practices to use on the same crop.
Irrigation type and practices Type of irrigation such as surface drip, sub-surface drip, micro-sprinklers, sprinklers, flood. Some irrigated types typically use more water because they are less efficient, and also promote non-beneficial ET through evaporation and encouraging weed growth.
Potential to decrease water use Relative — high, medium or low; annual ac-ft/yr of consumptive use. Water use on deficit-irrigated, low water use crops such as wine grapes is low compared to other crops that have high water use.
Time to implement Time to implement new practice and resultant time to realize water savings. Some measures may be immediate whereas others, like establishing or converting an irrigated vineyard to a dry farmed vineyard, is on the order of years.
Site factors
Accessibility Accessibility by people, animals, considering factors such as private property lines and terrain. Needed for evaluating suitability of recreation areas.
Suitability for farming Not all farmland is equally suited to being farmed successfully. Currently farmed sites which are poorly suited to being farmed due to slope, soil limitations, water limitations, frost risk, etc. are the best candidates to retire from production.
Climate Annual precipitation and summer season GDD. Climate varies within the Basin, partly because of distance from coast and elevation. Needed to evaluate crop types, farming practices.
Groundwater depletion Access to sufficient volumes of quality ground water is not equal over the Basin. Some areas of the Basin particularly near the boundaries may have shallower and/or poorer quality water which limits their suitability for farming.
Habitat connectivity Use natural lands layers in GIS to determine intersection/connectivity with natural and/or protected or preserved lands. Consider for siting and developing habitat areas.
Landscape — elevation and topography Percent slope, slope position, aspect, elevation. Needed to consider sites for solar and some alternative crops or cropping practices.
Proximity to jurisdictions/urban centers Using GIS proximity analysis; thresholds for evaluation TBD. Consider for developing recreation areas.
Recharge suitability Using Land IQ Recharge Suitability Index, which incorporates SAGBI and subsurface parameters from CVHM. Both surface and sub-surface factors need to be considered to site areas of potential recharge — infiltration rate and groundwater level.
Soil type General texture categories such as loam, sandy loam, clay loam, etc. Soil texture influences water infiltration and water holding capacity.
Storm/surface water availability Proximity to surface water features and/or existing and potential irrigation infrastructure. Needed for siting recharge areas and possibly other farming practices that could potentially use water sources other than groundwater.
Program/Basin factors
Local/Basin tourism E.g. extended fallowing may affect aesthetic value of local agriculture. Supports regional economy and direct farm sales.
Permitting, regulatory and legal Permitting, Williamson Act, Ordinance, existing easements, special land status. Effort and cost of permits.
Potential for measurement On-site monitoring. For measures not verifiable by measuring consumptive use.

Groundwater Sustainability Measures — Matrix

Evaluation factor Irrigation Cultural Stormwater Diff. Crop Ext. Fallow Dry Farm
Farm factors
Crop type X X X X X X
Typical water use X X X X X X
Farm practices X X X X X X
Irrigation type X X X X X X
Cost/revenue X X X X X X
Time to implement X X X X X X
Site factors
Soil type X X X X X X
Recharge suitability X X X
Landscape X X X X
Climate X X X X
Proximity to urban X X
Habitat connectivity X X
Accessibility X X X
Water availability X X
Program factors
Measurement potential X X X X X X
Tourism impact X X

Land Repurposing Measures — Matrix

Evaluation factor Recharge Habitat Solar Recreation
Farm factors
Crop type X X
Typical water use X
Cost/revenue X X X X
Time to implement X X X X
Site factors
Soil type X X
Recharge suitability X X
Landscape X X X
Proximity to urban X X X X
Habitat connectivity X X X
Accessibility X X X
Water availability X
Program factors
Measurement potential X
Tourism impact X X

Note: The guidebook uses “Recharge,” “Habitat,” “Solar,” and “Recreation” for the four land repurposing measure categories. Conservation cover and managed rangeland grazing are not shown as separate columns; consider applying the same site and program factors when evaluating those measures.

Summary by Measure (GSM)

Measure Crop Suitability Soil/Climate Key Factors
Cultural Practices Winegrapes, tree crops, annuals Varies by practice Mulch: availability, cost. Cover crop: rainfall, frost window.
Dry Farming Winegrapes, olives, some grains Adequate rainfall, coastal climate Rainfall >15 in/yr typical; rootstock, soil
Extended Fallow Perennial crops (vineyards, orchards) Any Crop removal cost, replant timing, market
Irrigation Practices All irrigated crops Any System type, age, DU, scheduling, recycled water
Stormwater Runoff Rangeland, grain, some vineyards Sloped land, runoff potential Topography, contour plowing, swales

Summary by Measure (LRM)

Measure Land Suitability Key Factors
Conservation Cover Former irrigated cropland Native/adapted species, establishment period
Habitat Restoration Riparian, wetland, floodplain Proximity to water, restoration potential
Managed Grazing Former cropland, adequate rainfall Forage species, stocking rate, water for livestock
Groundwater Recharge High infiltration soils, water access SAGBI, permits, water rights
Recreation Conversion Scenic, near population Community interest, liability, maintenance
Renewable Energy Solar resource, grid access Agrivoltaics vs ecovoltaics, permitting